|
Item |
Description |
|
Function |
Explains why a self-cleaning magnet captures manganese steel liners and how to stop it without losing real tramp iron protection |
|
Material in question |
Hadfield manganese steel (ASTM A128 type, 11–14% Mn, austenitic when annealed) |
|
Normal behavior |
Weak paramagnetism only — should slide off a magnet plate under its own weight |
|
When it becomes magnetic |
Work hardening, welding, incomplete solution annealing, or substitution with carbon steel |
|
Main risks |
Magnet belt damage, chute jamming, false tramp iron counts, steel contamination in product |
|
First check |
Material verification: magnet drop test + spark/spectro test + mill certificate |
|
Main fix |
Replace magnetic steel upstream; raise suspension height; select shallower field or trim electromagnet current |
The steel being picked up is a commodity story in itself. Ferro-alloy prices shape what foundries pour and what suppliers ship:
· Manganese: indicative manganese ore pricing sits near US$1,480/t, and chromium near US$9,200/t — elevated ferro-alloy input costs keep pressuring liner foundries and create incentives for substitution and mixed material lots, one root cause of "manganese steel" that is not manganese steel.
· Copper: COMEX copper fell to US$5.99/lb on 17 November (−0.19% on the day, −8.4% over the month, still +20.9% year-on-year); LME copper traded near US$13,375/t. Copper mines run some of the deepest-field tramp iron circuits in the industry, where the pickup of weakly magnetic debris is most often reported.
· Iron ore: spot prices eased about 2.5% to US$88.15/t. Lower ore prices squeeze margins and push plants to run equipment harder and longer — exactly the regime in which work-hardened liners end up on magnet belts.
· Gold: spot gold traded around US$3,852–3,865/oz after a rough week, with silver near US$47/oz. Gold operations using intense rare earth circuits report the most complaints about capturing weakly paramagnetic steel.
· Nickel: around US$14,449/t, up roughly 3.3% on the month — nickel-bearing austenitic alloys remain the standard fix for non-magnetic liner requirements.
Watch point: elevated ferro-alloy costs make material verification (mill certificates + spectro checks) more valuable than ever, because substitution risk rises whenever input prices do.
Direct answer: it is metallurgy, not magnet strength. Hadfield manganese steel contains 11–14% manganese, an element that stabilizes the austenitic crystal structure of the steel. When the casting or plate is correctly solution-annealed — heated to roughly 1,000–1,050 °C and rapidly water-quenched — the microstructure stays austenitic at room temperature. Austenite in this composition is paramagnetic, with a relative permeability of roughly 1.02–1.05. In practical terms: a genuine annealed Hadfield liner will not support its own weight on a magnet plate.
That is precisely why the mining industry uses manganese steel for impact-loaded wear parts in the first place. Jaw plates on a Jaw Crusher, concaves and mantles inside a Hydraulic Cone Crusher, and the liners inside SAG Mill Liners all rely on Hadfield steel's ability to work-harden under impact while the bulk of the part stays tough and — importantly for this article — essentially non-magnetic when new.
So when a self-cleaning Self-Cleaning Electromagnetic Separator keeps pulling "manganese steel" off the ore stream, something has changed on the material side or on the magnet side. Both sides are diagnosable, and the order of checks matters: verify the steel first, because it is free to check and statistically the most likely culprit.![]()
Q1: Is it normal for a self-cleaning magnet to pick up manganese steel at all?
A: No — not firmly. Annealed Hadfield manganese steel is paramagnetic and should slide off under its own weight. Weak cling of heavily work-hardened surfaces is possible; snap-on capture means the piece is carbon steel, welded, poorly annealed, or the field is unusually deep. Treat firm pickup as a material or specification problem first.
Q2: How can I test whether my "manganese steel" liner is genuine on site?
A: Start with a magnet drop test: annealed Hadfield will not support its own weight on a magnet plate. Then use a spark test for a coarse alloy check and a portable spectrometer for confirmation against the certificate. Any piece that snaps onto a handheld magnet like a tool deserves a spectro test before you blame the separator.
Q3: My magnet captures liners only after we weld repairs on them. Why?
A: Weld metal and the heat-affected zone develop magnetic phases even when the parent plate stays austenitic. On Hadfield steel, repair welding without proper control and re-annealing makes the repaired zone ferromagnetic. Verify repaired liners with a magnet test before returning them to the line, and prefer replacement over patching on impact-loaded parts.
Q4: Should I just lower the magnet current or buy a weaker magnet?
A: Not first. Weakening the magnet without fixing the material side trades real tramp iron protection for symptom relief — the crusher pays instead. Verify materials, remove magnetic steel upstream, then tune suspension height and only then consider field depth or current trim, validated with certified test pieces at every step.![]()
Contact: Annie Lu
Email: annie.lu@huataogroup.com
Phone / WhatsApp: +86 180 3242 2676
Website: http://www.tufflexscreen.com
We warmly welcome customers from around the world to contact us and establish mutually beneficial partnerships.
Contactpersoon: Mr. Maple
Tel.: +86 17778255675
Fax: 86--311-80690567